By Sam Kiley, Middle East Correspondent, in Umm al Hiran
Israeli government officials have rushed to defend the forced removal of up to 40,000 Israeli citizens of Arab descent from their homes in the Negev to new towns amid a growing clamour of protest and accusations that the policy is racist.
A bill that would enshrine the removal of thousands of Bedouin from their traditional lands and end a rural way of life dating back centuries is currently before the Israeli parliament, the Knesset.
But the removals have already begun.
Dozens of homes built in what the government calls "unrecognised villages" have been bulldozed over the last few years.
Ami Tesler: 'There is no racism here ... it's an opportunity'
And the village of Umm al Hiran has been served notice that it will be flattened, its 500 residents forced out, and a Jewish development built in its place.
Such events are commonplace on the Israeli occupied West Bank where Palestinians face severe construction limitations while illegal Jewish settlements continue a concrete march across Palestinian lands.
But the Negev plans in the Prawer-Begin Bill affect Bedouin who are ethnically Arab - but also full Israeli citizens.
Rabi Arik Ascherman, President of Rabbis for Human Rights, an Israeli human rights organisation said: "We are without a doubt treating the Bedouin in a way that we would not treat Jews in this country.
"The fact that the government has decided to build a Jewish community right where we're standing that Jewish community will get all of the services, all of the infrastructure, and there will be no question about it."
The Israeli plan is to move some 90,000 Bedouin from 36 villages into seven existing towns and another 11 which will be given recognition.
These Bedouin, who have a long history of loyalty to the Jewish State and send some 300 volunteers to the Israel Defence Force every year, will be given plots in planned areas with connections to water and electricity plus a grant of about £20,000 to build a home.
A Bedouin boy leans over tarpaulin in the Bir Mshash in Israel
Those who leave behind a tent or house may receive additional compensation of about £10,000.
The controversial plan is being run directly from the offices of Binyamin Netanyahu, the Israeli Prime Minister.
Ami Tesler, the head of the community relation department in the PM's "headquarters for Economic and Community Development of the Negev Bedouin" insist that most Bedouin would accept the "generous formula for compensation".
He admits, though, that the grant and compensation payments would not be enough to build a home "probably a caravan type place but if they work hard they can do much better".
"There is no racism here. On the contrary it's an opportunity for the Bedouins who were neglected because of many things. Now is the time to change this. It is the time to bring them to the 21st century.
"I think that what we are doing today is for the benefit of the Bedouins and especially for the young generation ... We want to give them an opportunity.
"And looking forward 20 years from now we want the babies of the Bedouin to have more education, more skills for life, so in the age of 18 they will have the same opportunities as my kids."
Bedouins ride donkeys in the West Bank Jewish settlement of Maale Adumim
In Uma al Hiran, children have a long bus ride and a dusty walk each way to and from a school in a "recognised" village.
But when they get home they are part of a tight-knit community rich in goats and sheep which was settled on this hill-top spot close to the West Bank when their ancestors were forced out of another Negev area by the Israeli army in 1956.
"We've done everything and now the state wants to bring Jews to replace us, and I say we should live here together.
"This is unacceptable, enough with the racism, enough with the hate," says Salim Abu Khian.
His son served in the IDF until recently.
He said that he did not want to move to a town and end the way of that still gave him access, just, to the freedom of the desert.
"The townships are full of crime and I don't want to bring my children up in that way of life," he said.
:: Watch Sky News live on television, on Sky channel 501, Virgin Media channel 602, Freeview channel 82 and Freesat channel 202.